[ bigvlada @ 27.08.2015. 09:08 ] @


Apple Inc. lost a ruling at Germany’s top civil court over a patent for unlocking smartphones with a finger swipe.


Judges on Tuesday said that the iPhone maker’s method didn’t reach a level of sophistication needed to award patent protection -- backing an earlier patent tribunal ruling in favor of Lenovo Group Ltd.’s Motorola Mobility Holdings Inc.

“This user-friendly display was already suggested by the state of the art,” the Karlsruhe-based court wrote. “The contested patent thus isn’t based on an invention.”

Apple’s German press office didn’t immediately reply to an e-mail seeking comment.

Samsung Electronics Co. had initially joined Motorola Mobility in the case, but later withdrew.

In 2012, Apple won a Munich court injunction against Motorola Mobility based on the patent. That case is pending on appeal and was stayed to wait for the outcome of Tuesday’s suit.

Today’s case is BGH, X ZR 110/13.

http://www.bloomberg.com/news/...se-over-swipe-to-unlock-patent

Jedno ludilo manje. Ne tako veliko kao parnica protiv Microsofta i Digital Research-a zbog Windows-a i GEM-a ali je ipak ludilo. U tim davnim vremenima zbog sličnih gluposti svaki program je imao drugačije prečice na tastaturi, bile su potrebne godine da dođemo do univerzalnog svetog dualiteta: ctrl+c i ctrl+v.
[ Ivan Dimkovic @ 27.08.2015. 12:54 ] @
Problem sa tim stvarima je sto danas velike firme patentiraju bukvalno sve.

U Evropi malo teze prolaze aplikacije od USA, ali je USA najbitnije trziste - troskovi "obaranja" patenta na sudu su veliki, sve i da imas 100% sanse moraces da finansiras spor dok traje.

Velike firme odbijaju medjusobno "rokanje" osim ako nije doslo do "rata" - ovo sa Apple-om i Motorolom bas kao i Apple i Samsung su relativno retke stvari koje kace malo patenata. Sve i da rezultati svih tih sporova budu osporavanje patenata, to samo znaci da ce par desetina / max. stotina patenata biti "ubijeno".

Medjutim samo dok ti sporovi traju, podneseno je i odobreno sigurno na hiljade patenata.